콘텐츠로 건너뛰기
블로그로 돌아가기

영어 원본

Benchmark · Tanks and Temples

From 301 photos to a 3D scene: the Train benchmark

Bring the locomotive’s shape, markings and texture from photographs into a 3D scene. Train’s PSNR, SSIM and LPIPS improve on the cited 3DGS paper values on all three tested platforms, with LPIPS about 30% lower.

MakeWorlds team · Tested

MakeWorlds render of the Train locomotive’s front and body
Original photograph of the same Train front and body view
Original photoMakeWorlds render

Mac · view-000009 · Front and body

MakeWorlds render of the Train scene from an oblique viewpoint
Original photograph of the same oblique Train viewpoint
Original photoMakeWorlds render

Mac · view-000057 · Oblique overview

MakeWorlds render of the Train locomotive’s side texture
Original photograph of the same Train side viewpoint
Original photoMakeWorlds render

Mac · view-000249 · Side texture

Look closer at the details

Detail of the body markings in the MakeWorlds render
The same body markings in the original photograph
Body markings and paint texture

Detail of the steps and railings in the MakeWorlds render
The same steps and railings in the original photograph
Steps and railings

Both detail comparisons use the front-and-body viewpoint with identical zoom and framing. The original photo is on the left and the MakeWorlds render is on the right.

Compared with the 3DGS paper baseline

Train improves on the cited paper baseline in PSNR, SSIM and LPIPS on all three tested platforms. LPIPS measures perceptual image differences; lower is better. In this round it is 29.5%–29.9% lower than the cited paper value.

Train · Medium · 30,000 steps · means over all evaluated test views
Δ = MakeWorlds − paper. Higher PSNR / SSIM and lower LPIPS are better.
ResultPSNR ↑ / dBSSIM ↑LPIPS ↓
3DGS paper baseline21.0970.80200.2180
MakeWorlds · Mac21.227Δ +0.1300.8463Δ +0.04430.1537Δ −0.0643
MakeWorlds · Linux21.282Δ +0.1850.8479Δ +0.04590.1528Δ −0.0652
MakeWorlds · Windows21.205Δ +0.1080.8468Δ +0.04480.1530Δ −0.0650

The baseline is the 30,000-step row in appendix Tables 7–9 of the 3DGS paper. Metrics cover all evaluated test views; images are selected display views. Read the paper · Tanks and Temples

Test conditions and sources
Input
301 photographs, all cameras successfully registered
Settings
Medium tier, source resolution, 30,000 steps
Hardware
Mac: Apple M4 Max; Linux and Windows: NVIDIA RTX 4090
Mac evaluation
19 fixed test views, using cameras solved by the product.
Images
Selected Mac test views view-000009, view-000057 and view-000249, pairing renders and original photographs from the same evaluation.

Keep reading

Selected public scenes tested on Mac, Windows and Linux